Should you fix your broken item or buy a new one? Enter the details below and we'll analyze which option makes more financial sense.
How long you've owned it
What you paid for it
Quoted repair price
Expected lifespan after repair
Cost of a new replacement
Expected lifespan of replacement
How often you use it annually
Enter details about your current product: its age, original price, and current condition.
Add the repair quote and expected lifespan after repair, plus the cost and lifespan of a replacement.
We'll analyze costs, compare 5-year projections, and give you a clear recommendation with reasoning.
The 50% rule suggests that if a repair costs more than 50% of what it would cost to replace the item, you should replace it instead. However, this is a general guideline—our calculator considers additional factors like remaining lifespan, condition, and environmental impact.
Repair is usually better when: the repair cost is low relative to replacement, the item is high quality and will last many more years after repair, the item has sentimental value, or finding an equivalent replacement is difficult. BIFL (Buy It For Life) products are often worth repairing.
Replace is usually better when: the item is already near the end of its lifespan, repair costs approach or exceed replacement cost, the item is in poor overall condition with multiple issues, or newer models offer significant improvements in efficiency or features.
Consider the type of repair: minor fixes might add 1-2 years, major component replacements 3-5 years, and full refurbishments can extend life by 5-10+ years. Research the typical lifespan for your product and how much life remains. Ask repair professionals for their estimates.
Yes! Repairing almost always has a lower environmental impact than replacing. Manufacturing new products requires significant resources and energy. If both options are financially similar, choosing repair is better for the planet.
The best products to own are those designed to be repaired. Explore our recommendations for durable, repairable gear.